Almost Debt Free: Good Debt vs. Bad Debt
@ 8:57 am“When you live on cash, you understand the limits of the world around which you navigate each day. Credit leads into a desert with invisible boundaries.” -Anton Chekhov
Almost Debt Free is a bit of a misnomer for this new series that I will publish each Tuesday into the summer. I’m actually looking forward to running into the arms of mortgage debt and a small business loan. It’s credit card debt that I’d like to see kicked to the curb, which I’m four months from successfully divorcing.
I will not lie. My debt reduction experience was a tumultuous undertaking. I’ve worked long, strenuous hours to make more money; I’ve strained friendships with my unavailability; and I’ve had to completely re-evaluate my priorities, my interests, and an overall understanding of myself. I wouldn’t recommend the militant approach I applied to debt reduction. It is the last year of being in my twenties, and I essentially had a freak out several years in the making. I can’t complain really. It was vitally important for me to be prepared to jump into my thirties with a brighter financial future, and that’s what I have accomplished.
It’s sad that my story is rare, and I don’t think it should be. Although it irritates me when others preach the “if I can do it, anyone can” drill we’ve all heard before, I’m going to drop that line here as well. I grew up a spoiled brat with no appreciation for the value of a dollar, and my attitude about work and earning money was bad enough to make me the most unsympathetic of characters. Somehow, I stumbled into debt and crawled out of a potentially gloomy picture entirely on my own.
We all have different reasons for how we got into debt, but as Tamara Draut points out in her book Strapped: Why America’s 20- and 30-Somethings Can’t Get Ahead, those of us born between 1971 and 1987 face greater financial barriers to transitioning to adulthood than the Baby Boomer generation before us. With backbreaking education and housing costs, diminishing work and tax benefits, and easy access to credit cards, it’s plain to see how credit card debt carried by the average American is $8,562.
Here’s my intent for this series. I’m not going to give financial advice, because I’m not qualified to do that. I’m going to frankly chronicle my last days of credit card debt, and I’ll share what I’m doing to prepare for life after debt. It’s my hope that others will see it is absolutely possible to take control of their financial situation and get to a similar position as me. Whether you’re deep in the red, or already in the black, the topics I will cover have something for everyone.
To kickoff this series, let me distinguish between good debt and bad debt. It’s the bad debt I want to identify and get rid of, and it’s the good the debt I want to manage slowly but effectively while saving for other things.
Experts will tell you, in the most helpful way they can, not all debt is bad, not all debt is good, but it’s a little more complicated than that.
Let’s clarify the distinction with my case. I have gone back up to $4,000 in credit card debt, all but $500 of which is locked in at a 0% interest rate relatively soon to expire. My student loan debt is just under $10,000 at 6.8% interest. I have no mortgage, no car payments, and low monthly utility expenses. What’s the good debt? What’s the bad debt?
Bankrate.com (via MSN Money) provides some great rules of thumb.
Good Debt: An investment that creates value and builds wealth (ie, student loan, home and business loans).
Bad Debt: Purchase that goes down in value or has no potential to increase in value (ie, disposable or durable goods).
That’s pretty easy to grasp, but I’ll echo the experts and say it’s a little more complicated than that. My student loan isn’t entirely good debt because half of it was for a random semester of school I did after graduating college to break from the rat race. That creative writing semester hasn’t really added much to my earning potential. I learned the hard way that I should take education and career a bit more seriously.
Also, I was grim to discover this past tax season that a significant portion of interest I paid on my student loan in 2006 could not be deducted because the benefit gets phased out for my income range, a tax pitfall I wish were more widely available knowledge. Those who made more than $65K in 2006 didn’t even get to deduct any student loan interest.
Good debt falls into a bit more of a gray area. Take current real estate market conditions, for example. Nina pointed out that many sub-prime borrowers are hurting significantly from their home loans, while I discussed that home values are stagnating or even depreciating in some parts of the country. Auto loans are another gray area. It’s a necessary expenditure for some, but there is risk for driving too much car. I’ll talk more about managing good and gray debts later in this series.
Thankfully bad debt is pretty clear. For me, and this is my personal opinion, but credit card debt simply sucks. It’s bad debt, and it’s best to live without it.
Most of us already know that partial monthly payments and high interest rates are what have kept us in debt. I’m not advocating life without credit cards, however, because it’s not wise. We need a credit card to develop and maintain a credit history that shows creditors we are responsible with money, as Paula discusses. It just comes down to managing life with credit cards and staying out of bad debt as your money goes toward building wealth. That’s the focus of this series, and that’s all there is to it.
Stay tuned for next week where I talk about how I got organized to pay down my debts, and the risky debt ratio I’m riding that you definitely want to avoid on the debt reduction path.








May 15th, 2007 at 11:38 am
Hey John
Great post. It reminds me so much of my own story. A major step is understanding what is good debt and what is bad debt. For so long I was comfortable with credit card debt and couldn’t face the facts that this was eating away at my financial position. Now I see it for what it is & am doing everything I can to keep it out of my life!
Jack B/
May 16th, 2007 at 8:27 am
Great post & can’t wait for the series.
The only time I see credit card debt as maybe OK is if you’re using business credit cards to build a business. While a loan “might” be better, depending on the amount, doing it the credit card way might be one way to make it happen. Again, a plan and revenue stream to pay it off is crucial…
May 21st, 2007 at 3:00 pm
As you said cc debt sucks. It’s been also said good debt is less 10% interest ( home, student loans)
May 21st, 2007 at 4:09 pm
Part of the 101st edition of Carnival of Personal Finance:
http://firefinance.blogspot.com/2007/05/101st-edition-of-carnival-of-personal.html
May 22nd, 2007 at 11:03 am
[...] Almost Debt Free: Good Debt vs. Bad Debt at Queercents [...]
May 22nd, 2007 at 11:45 am
[...] So now you know the difference between good debt and bad debt, and you’d like to get rid of the bad debt. But if you got into debt in the first place, how are you ever going to have enough money to get out of it? [...]
May 23rd, 2007 at 4:45 pm
[...] The first is from The Happy Rock, who talks about getting out of debt and all the happy things that go along with being debt free. I can really relate to the “less stress” comment. Although I literally have nearly 100 times more debt from my mortgage and student loans, I kind of stress about my credit card debt, probably because I know that the mortgage and student loans are the good debt, while the credit card debt is just from “other” purchases and is bad debt. This is a nice connection to the post from Queercents, who talks about the different between good and bad debt. I’m trying to reduce the credit card debt, but it’s like a yo-yo diet: it goes up and down, usually within a range of almost being debt free to very stress inducing. [...]
June 13th, 2007 at 4:03 am
[...] In this series about preparing for life after debt and how to get there, I’ve covered how to identify bad debt; ways of organizing your finances to reduce bad debt; ideas for implementing a functional budget; and I released the Queercents Expense Tracker to make developing or staying within a budget easier. (Side note: It turns out the Queercents Expense Tracker is functional on both MS Excel and Open Office.) [...]
October 5th, 2007 at 2:59 pm
[...] Queercents get personal in Almost Debt Free: Good Debt vs Bad Debt. The key point here is in his discussion about student loans where he points out that some of it is good, and some of it is not so good. [...]
November 19th, 2007 at 7:38 pm
[...] you learn to take control over your credit cards and your debt, you learn how to make these tools work for you. My partner [...]